Skip to content
4th Turning Strategy
Insights
Strategy

The asset your equity investors are not pricing

Fran Strajnar · 6 min read

Equity investors value a company on its blend. A software business with high gross margins that also owns a network of physical assets with low ones does not get a software multiple on the software and an infrastructure multiple on the infrastructure. It gets one number, and that number usually sits closer to the weaker half.

Frontier companies run into this more than most. A space data company owns ground stations. A robotics company owns machines on customer sites. An AI company owns or leases compute. Each of those assets has investors who would value it properly, and few of them are on the company's cap table.

A precedent from telecoms

Mobile operators faced the same problem with their towers. In March 2021 Vodafone listed Vantage Towers in Frankfurt, a separate company holding about 82,000 sites across ten European markets, valued at up to €14.7 billion at the top of its price range. Vodafone's networks stayed on as the anchor tenant, and Vantage set out to host other operators on the same towers.1 Infrastructure investors bought a steady, contracted asset. Vodafone kept the service business and raised capital from something its own shareholders had been valuing as part of a telecoms company.

BEFOREAFTEREquity investorsone blended multipleOperating companysoftware + heavy assetEquityAsset investorsOperating co.keeps its multipleAsset co.secured notecontract
Before and after: one blended valuation, then two businesses funded on their own terms.

How the structure works

  1. A separate company holds the asset. Ground stations, machines, compute or energy, with their own accounts and management.
  2. A contract connects the two. The operating company buys capacity or service at arm's length, on terms an outside investor would accept.
  3. The asset company raises its own capital. Secured notes, infrastructure equity or project finance, from investors who want exactly that kind of asset. Tokenized notes can widen that group further.
  4. The operating company keeps its equity story. Its investors fund the part of the business they understand, at the multiple they apply to it.

When it works and when it does not

The structure works when the asset has demand beyond the parent, when the contract between the two would stand up on its own, and when the asset company can be governed separately. It works poorly when the parent is the only customer, because investors then price the parent's risk into the asset anyway, and when the cost of running two companies outweighs the difference in valuation.

The tax, accounting and legal questions are real and specific to each jurisdiction. They belong with counsel early, before anyone falls in love with the diagram.

Questions for the board

  • Which assets on our balance sheet would a specialist investor value more highly than our shareholders do?
  • Who else would buy what those assets produce?
  • What would the contract between the two companies look like, and would we sign it as strangers?
  • Does separating them give us more options later, such as selling one or bringing in a partner?

Notes and sources

  1. TelecomTV, Vantage Towers IPO values company at up to €14.7 billion, March 2021

Every turning rewards the prepared.

Tell us where you are. We will be candid about what comes next, whether or not we end up working together.